 |
The Council, Siege and Rout of
Winchester

The Civil War of King Stephen's Reign was a
time of oscillating loyalties especially amongst
the rich and powerful. Even the King's own
brother, the Bishop of Winchester, Henry of Blois, was not beyond
changing sides. His support tended to tip the
balance of power between Stephen and his rival to
the throne, the Empress Matilda. Although this
brought great prestige to his hometown, it also
brought great dangers.  
Having captured King Stephen at the Battle of
Lincoln in February 1141, the Empress Matilda
spent most of the year trying to consolidate her de
facto position as Queen of England. The
powerful Henry of Blois was not among the
immediate rush of English nobles clammering to
submit to the Empress, but the Bishop's
differences with his brother, the King,
eventually persuaded him to give way to pressure
from Matilda and Earl Robert of Gloucester. On
2nd March, Bishop Henry agreed to meet with the
Empress and most of the English Nobility outside
the gates of Winchester. The day was grey and
overcast and rain began to pelt down on the two
parties as the Empress promised "that all
matters of chief account in England, especially
gifts of bishoprics and abbacies, should be
subject to his control if he received her in Holy
Church as lady, and kept his faith to her
unbroken". Bishop Henry agreed to recognise
the Empress as Queen so long as she kept her side
of this bargain.
The following day, Matilda was publicly
welcomed into Winchester. She took up residence
in the Castle and Bishop Henry handed over to her
the keys to the Treasury and the Royal Crown. He
then arranged a large meeting of the citizens of
Winchester in the Market Place so they could
salute her as "their Lady and their
Queen". From here, the party entered the
cathedral with great pomp. Matilda led the
procession with Henry of Blois to her right and
the Bishop of St. Davids to her left. Relatives
of the Bishops of Salisbury, Ely and Lincoln were
also present and Henry sent for Archbishop
Theobald of Canterbury who arrived a few days
later.
Theobald and other bishops were reluctant to
abandon King Stephen. So, while the Empress moved
north to Oxford in triumph, a Church Council was
called at Winchester. The monkish writer, William
of Malmesbury, was amongst the attendants, so
there are detailed accounts in existence. Henry
of Blois explained his change of stance as being
due to King Stephen having broken his promises to
the church. He was keen to remind those present
of the arrest of three bishops two years
previously and pompously declared that though
"I should love my mortal brother, I should
esteem far more highly the cause of my immortal
Father". The church did not want a country
without a ruler and secret meetings with Henry
soon brought them round to his way of thinking.
However, during the Spring and early
Summer, things did not run so smoothly for the
Empress elsewhere. She needed the support of the
City of London in order to take her place solidly
on the throne and secure her coronation; but she
treated the citizens with contempt and demanded
taxation. When Stephen's Queen raised an army and
marched south, she was soon joined by the
Londoners and the Empress was forced to flee the
City. It was not long before the Queen had
persuaded Bishop Henry to join his brother's camp
once more.

Bishop Henry returned to Winchester determined
to turn the city back to the Royalist cause and
immediately set about besieging the Empress'
forces in the Castle. Matilda responded quickly
and arrived with her own besieging army on 31st
July. The Bishop of Winchester's men were forced
to retreat behind the walls of Wolvesey Palace,
his residence in the city which had been
fortified ready for any attack. The Bishop
himself managed to escape and rode east for
reinforcements from the Queen. A double siege
ensued: the Royalists and London militia
blockading the whole city, while, within, the
Imperialists besieged the Bishop's men.
Three days later, Winchester was set on fire,
probably by the Imperialists at Wolvesey. St.
Mary's Nunnaminster, Hyde Abbey and the Royal
Palace were all burnt to the ground. Matilda all
but lost her remaining provisions and the siege
lasted only a month before she was forced to make
a break for it. A diversionary attack under
Robert of Gloucester was arranged for 14th
September, possibly helped by events at nearby
Wherwell. During the fighting, Matilda managed to
flee the city to Ludgershall, Devizes and then
Gloucester. The story that she was smuggled out
in a lead coffin is almost certainly apocryphal.
Earl Robert was not as lucky as his half-sister.
He followed the Empress, but held back with his
forces to protect her escape. He was captured at
the Battle of Stockbridge.
The citizens of Winchester saw no thanks for
their part in helping the Royalist cause. The
London militia sacked the city. Houses, shops and
churches were all wrecked and many captives
dragged away for torture and execution.
Sources
..............
Martin Biddle & Beatrice
Clayre (1983) Winchester Castle and the Great
Hall
Jim Bradbury (1996) Stephen
and Matilda: The Civil War of 1139-53
Tom Beaumont James (1997) Winchester
Elizabeth Lewis (1978) A
Prospect of Winchester
Barry Shurlock (1986) The Winchester Story
Barbara Carpenter Turner (1980) Winchester
Copyright ©1996, 1997, 1998, 1999 Britannia Internet Magazine. Design by Unica Multimedia |