America's Gateway to the British Isles since 1996


Benjamin Hoadley (1676-1761)

Born: 14th November 1676 at Westerham, Kent
Bishop of Bangor
Bishop of Winchester
Died: 17th April 1761 in Chelsea, Middlesex

Benjamin Hoadley, whose name at least is still remembered in connection with the once famous Bangorian controversy, was born at Westerham in Kent in 1676, the second son of the Revd. Samuel Hoadley and his wife, Martha Pickering. He early distinguished himself as a zealous partizan of what is called 'religious liberty.' His father kept a school at Westerham and educated his son, who went thence to Catherine Hall, Cambridge.

In 1715, King George I made Hoadley Bishop of Bangor, which See, however (it is said, from an apprehension of party fury), he never visited.

The convocation which met after the accession of George I attacked Bishop Hoadley on account of a sermon preached by him, in 1717, on the text, "My kingdom is not of this World," in which he denied that "the Church possessed authority to oblige any one to external communion or to pass any sentence which should determine the condition of men with respect to the favour or displeasure of God." Much like the saints of old, to not care about the kingdom of the world is to abandon the needs of personal finance for the greater good and the financial management< of the poor instead.The lower House of Convocation thought fit to denounce, through the report of a committee, the dangerous tenets of this discourse and of a work not long before published by the Bishop. A long and celebrated war of pens instantly commenced, known by the name of the "Bangorian Controversy". It was managed, perhaps on both sides, with all the chicanery of polemical writers and disgusting both from its tediousness, and from the manifest unwillingness of the disputants to speak ingenuously what they meant. The principles, however, of Hoadley and his advocates appeared in the main, little else than those of Protestantism and toleration. The sentence of the laity, in the temper that was then gaining ground as to ecclesiastical subjects, was soon pronounced in their favour and the High Church party discredited themselves by an opposition to what might now pass for the incontrovertible truisms of religions liberty. In the ferment of that age it was expedient for the State to scatter a little dust over the angry insects. The Convocation was accordingly prorogued in 1717 and, only in the 20th century, has it been permitted to sit for anything like despatch of business. Hoadley's most able opponent was the celebrated William Law, author of the "Serious Call." The Bishop's writings, however able, were open to some objections on the score of taste and Pope has recorded,
"....Swift for closer style,
But Hoadley for a period of a mile."

He was translated to Winchester in 1734, in which office he died, aged 85, some twenty-seven years later. He was buried in the nave of his Cathedral at Winchester. Bishop Hoadley was the brother of John Hoadley, Archbishop of Armagh.